← All tournaments
Australasian Intervarsity Debating Championships 2016
2016-07-15 · AP
Part of the Australasian Intervarsity Debating Championship (Australs) series →
Motions from this series
Australs 2016 (2016)42 motions
- Round 1That where private prisons exist, they should be allowed to train/educate inmates in return for a percentage of that prisoner’s income that they earn after they leave prison.
- Round 1That we should ban litigation funding.
- Round 1That the state should fully compensate the victims of crimes committed by recidivist criminals.
- Round 2That we should allow people to sue media companies over harms that are created due to factual misinformation that they published.
- Round 2That we should regret dating/hookup websites allowing their users filtering results on the basis of demographic characteristics (race, gender, age etc.)
- Round 2That Facebook should proactively suppress extremist content
- Round 3That we should reject the culture of fearing death.
- Round 3That we would prefer a world with only one language.
- Round 3That humans should attempt to suppress their sense of beauty.
- Round 4That public universities should not implement speech codes or codes of conduct that limit expression beyond the laws of that country.
- Round 4That we should regret the increasing dominance of academic discourse in civil rights movements (eg gender studies to feminism and queer studies to that queer rights movement)
- Round 4That universities and companies should only be allowed to recruit students and employees via a blind application process.
- Round 5That we should ban animal eugenics programmes (eg: selective breeding and pure breeding)
- Round 5That we should cease all state initiated conservation projects
- Round 5That we should oppose giving human rights to individual animals who pass self-recognition tests unless the whole species are granted those rights
- Round 6That citizenships should be placed on an international market for sale and purchase.
- Round 6That the European Union should opt for less integration among its current member states.
- Round 6That refugees should be able to bypass standard refugee quotas and procedures if they have an individual citizen take responsibility for them.
- Round 7That we should legalise secondary strikes/solidarity action. (industrial action taken by a workforce in support of another, separate workforce)
- Round 7That we should allow employees to give up workplace rights in exchange for higher wages.
- Round 7That we would prefer a world where the norm is that people hold multiple part time jobs instead of the current norm of one full time job.
- Round 8That where the state has negotiated a sale of public land they must first offer indigenous groups the chance to purchase the land on the same terms.
- Round 8That the state should exclusively focus on recifying current inequalities to the exclusion of compensating for historical injustices
- Round 8That local communities should be able to cap the number of tourists that enter their region over a specific period of time
- Open OctofinalsThat, where home schooling exists, we should ban religious individuals from homeschooling their children.
- Open OctofinalsThat we, as the Catholic Church, would abolish sainthoods and canonisation.
- Open OctofinalsThat individuals should always have the right to temporarily enter a state for the purposes of pilgrimage.
- ESL SemifinalsThat the narrative that charitable initiatives can be profitable (eg microfinancing, impact investment) has done more harm than good.
- ESL SemifinalsThat charities should not accept donations made by public figures as part of a public apology (eg public figures who are criticised for being misogynists and then donate to domestic violence charities).
- ESL SemifinalsThat the state should not provide legal recognition and support to charities whose main goal is to raise awareness.
- Open QuarterfinalsThat we regret the efforts of the United States to make housing more affordable.
- Open QuarterfinalsThat we, as China, should compensate venture capital/private equity firms for investment losses in China.
- Open QuarterfinalsThat the pro-Palestine movement should not liken Israel to apartheid.
- Open SemifinalsThat we should abolish corporate/company tax.
- Open SemifinalsThat we should establish an international body responsible for taxing and redistributing income earned by multi-national corporations such as Facebook and Google.
- Open SemifinalsThat we should allow income splitting. (Income splitting allows a person to allocate part of their income to their partner for tax purposes. Eg Kirkby earns $0, Nick earns $100,000. Each is taxed at $50,000 each. It is not taxing them at $100,000 as if they are one person.)
- ESL Grand FinalThat we should oppose the Teach for All programme.
- ESL Grand FinalThat as a middle class African-American parent, given the choice between an under-performing but predominantly African American school and a high performing but predominantly white school, we should choose to send our children to the predominantly African-American school.
- ESL Grand FinalThat we should give control of education curriculum administration and policy (eg teacher pay and curricula) to teachers’ unions.
- Open Grand FinalThat the modern breast feeding movement has done more harm than good
- Open Grand FinalThat feminists should oppose drag culture
- Open Grand FinalThat feminists should refrain from using the act of sex to further their personal or political goals
Australs 2015 (2015)45 motions
- Round 1That we should prohibit police departments from having specialised public relations staff
- Round 1That jurors should be allowed to directly cross examine witnesses
- Round 1That we should remove statutes of limitation for all crimes
- Round 2That those who live in states that suffer rampant corruption should evade tax
- Round 2That we welcome China's establishment of the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank as an alternative to the International Monetary Fund
- Round 2That we should allow citizens to donate to recognised charities of their own choosing instead of paying income tax
- Round 3That we should refrain from characterising villains of history as monsters
- Round 3That curricula in post-colonial states should focus on locally-authored literature, to the absolute exclusion of 'great work' such as Shakespeare
- Round 3That the media should have suppressed any reference to Dylan Roof's mental illness, and instead focus exclusively on racism as an explanation for Charleston massacre.
- Round 4That we should make Boards of Trustees at colleges and universities personally liable for sexual crimes committed by their students against other students
- Round 4That any potential romantic partners or professional sports players should deny them all physical and emotional contact until clubs and sports authorities agree to structural reforms to combat sexism
- Round 4That we should permanently remove men who abuse their partners from secluded communities where domestic violence is entrenched.
- Round 5That Germany should prosecute United States government officials for torture in German courts, regardless of their participation in the trial
- Round 5That member states of the International Criminal Court should be required to violate sovereignty to make arrests on behalf of the ICC
- Round 5That we regret the Arabisation of Islam in South East Asia
- Round 6That as a progressive person, we regret the changes made to the Catholic Church and its direction ushered in by Pope Francis
- Round 6That religious organisations should be exempt from employment discrimination law when hiring for 'non-religious' roles (e.g. secretaries, doctors, contractors)
- Round 6That we regret the involvement of the church, its leaders and the language of religion (i.e. redemption, absolution) in truth and conciliation processes.
- Round 7presuming it were possible, That we would opt for a digital existence over a physical one
- Round 7presuming feasibility, That we should allow individuals to selectively erase others' memories of them
- Round 7in a world where it exists, That love with artificial intelligence is as valid as love with a human
- Round 8That we regret Iraq's policy of offering its citizens large sums of money to personally kill terrorist militants
- Round 8That Western states should block ransom payments made by families for the release of ISIS captives
- Round 8in the face of an overwhelming failure of conventional responses by nation-states, That churches should encourage and materially support able members of their congregation to go and fight against ISIS
- Open OctofinalsThat criminal justice policy should be outsourced to technocrats in place of elected representatives
- Open OctofinalsThat political parties should be compelled to retain membership racially proportional to the population
- Open OctofinalsThat within progressive social justice movements, allies from majorities ought to remain silent
- EFL SemifinalsThat governments who fail to disaster-proof should be held liable for the deaths of their citizens in the event of a natural disaster
- EFL SemifinalsThat Greece should sell sovereign control over portions of its territory to private companies in order to finance its debt repayment
- EFL SemifinalsThat we celebrate the proliferation of regionally specific human rights instruments such as the Arab Charter on Human Rights, despite deviations from the Universal Declaration of Human Rights
- Open QuarterfinalsThat states should not enter into international agreements that contain investor-state dispute settlement provisions
- Open QuarterfinalsThat we should require companies that develop innovations disrupting established industries to pay compensation to the labour forces they make redundant
- Open QuarterfinalsThat we should privatise the ocean
- Open SemifinalsThat faced with a choice between purchasing desirable but non-essential products (e.g. Starbucks) over spending on alleviating suffering (e.g. donating to charity), that we ought to always do the latter
- Open SemifinalsThat we should not prosecute those who, for reasons of mercy, kill family members who are physically or mentally incapable of consenting to death
- Open SemifinalsThat the government should pre-emptively and aggressively intervene in individuals' lives based on data-driven predictions in areas such as health, education and crime
- EFL Grand FinalThat companies should be compelled to finance their female employees to freeze their eggs and subsequently undergo in vitro fertilisation (IVF)
- EFL Grand FinalWhere conflicts have disproportionately harmed women, That post-conflict states should exclusively appoint women to positions of leadership in the military
- EFL Grand FinalThat we should prosecute fathers who choose to walk out on their children for criminal negligence, irrespective of whether they pay child support
- ESL Grand FinalThat journalists and media organisations who cover conflicts should be required to render reasonable assistance to the victims, even where it directly jeopardises their coverage
- ESL Grand FinalThat living people owe a moral obligation to preserve an equivalent to present standard of living for future generations
- ESL Grand FinalThat we should demonise neutral states that refrain from taking action in conflicts with a definitely identifiable oppressor
- Open Grand FinalThat we regret the commercialisation of Pride
- Open Grand FinalThat African Americans should embrace claims made by white individuals, such as Rachel Dolezal, to identify as part of their community
- Open Grand FinalThat we cannot achieve social justice
Breaking here
24% of teams break
Teams usually guarantee their break on 7 points.
Last edition: 18 of 74 teams broke.
- 20157 pts19/78
- 20167 pts18/74
~??% estimated break chance
??.?–??.? estimated speaker score
Sign in to see your personal estimates.
Break categories
This tournament runs a separate break for each category. From the most recent edition:
- Open break18 teams
- ESL break6 teams
Sign in to see the rest: scoring culture, who’s judging, similar tournaments, and your break chances.
Sign in to unlock