Arts & Culture motions
5 practice motions with a level, and 188 more set at tournaments. Each one opens a prep clock.
Motions start with TH, short for This House (the debate itself), then the first letters of a verb:
- THW
- would
- THBT
- believes that
- THS
- supports
- THO
- opposes
- THR
- regrets
- THP
- prefers
Practice motions
5 with a levelChosen for practice and sorted by level. The same 5 are under Arts & Culture on the Motions page.
THS the aggressive use of blind casting in art and entertainment
THBT the globalisation of art has done more harm than good
THP a world where art is submitted to and displayed in galleries anonymously
THW allow national governments to veto the removal of culturally significant works of art from their country
THP the quality of art being viewed as predominantly subjective as opposed to predominantly objective
Set at tournaments
188 motionsFrom public tabs, newest first. Tidied for reading (stray quotes, labels and footnote marks removed), English only, repeats left out.
In Western academic institutions, THP the housing, studying, and teaching of AOA (Africa, Oceania and the Americas) artifacts in art history departments rather than anthropology departments.
TH opposes the shift towards evaluating art for its abstract qualities rather than technical craftsmanship
TH, as the Nobel Prize Committee in 2019, Would rescind Peter Handke's Literature Prize
TH, as this individual, W publicly call for the return the Benin Bronzes.
THBT universities and literary institutions should prioritize publishing and canonizing unpublished works of historical female writers over the ones of current female writers
THO cultural organisations (e.g. museums, theatres, film festivals) justifying their value in terms of measurable public returns (e.g. jobs, tourism, economic regeneration, societal impacts)
THO market-oriented art
THP a world where postcolonial writers prioritized writing in their indigenous languages, rather than writing in global lingua francas e.g., English, French, etc.
THP a world where society celebrates the concept of art which rejects commercial success, even at the cost of material hardship.
THP the essentialist model to the relationist model of art education
THR the rise of auteur cinema
THW have artistic awards (e.g. Oscars, Grammys, Cannes Film Festival) decided exclusively by the audience
THW impose quotas to require more minority identity nominees in major award bodies (e.g., the Nobel, Booker, Oscars, Grammys, etc.)
This House Prefers Protest Art to be Anonymous
This House Prefers art that depicts societal tragedies through allegories (The Yellow Wallpaper, Animal Farm, The Platform) over art that depicts societal tragedies explicitly (Schindler's List, Apocalypse Now, 12 Years a Slave).
This House Regrets the "Art is Dead" narrative.
This House opposes the use of indigenous and minority culture in fantasy and science fiction worldbuilding (e.g., the Dune Franchise, Aladdin)
This House regrets the prevalence of sampling in music
This house believes that all art displayed in public institutions should be presented without any information on the creator (including name, country of origin, background information, etc).
This house prefers photography to literature as an artistic medium for evoking the sublime. *non-video
This house prefers that works about artists who have taken their own lives (e.g., biographies, commentaries, the editorial framing of posthumous releases of their work) focus on their ambitions over their struggles.
This house regrets the cultural veneration of old art at the expense of new art.
This house would abolish gendered categories in art awards (e.g. the Oscars, Grammys)
TH prefers a world where the artistic norm for theatre is one of travelling rather than stationing
TH, as a second generation immigrant artist, would actively use their culture of their origin in their artworks as opposed to appealing to the mainstream culture.
THBT art should be competitively evaluated on its technical aspects over its emotional feeling
THBT exclusive art spaces do more harm than good
THBT the state should ban the creation, distribution and displays of art which involve elements of self harm (e.g. "The Starving Artist", exhibitions which involve artists in uncomfortable positions for long periods of time, blood painting, etc.)
THP a world where all art is pseudonymous
THP a world where the common convention for mystery literature is Rashomon-style as opposed to single-narrative style
Where these were set
Tournament series whose editions have set Arts & Culture motions. Each series page lists the motions from every edition we have a tab for.